Dear Authors,
your paper has been revised by two reviewers. They raised minor to major issues. I agree with them. In the open discussion you provided detailed replies. I think you should have a chance to propose a revised version of your work after major changes. If you are willing to make the necessary revisions, I will be pleased to reconsider your submission, with the help of the same reviewers who examined the present work.
In submitting your revised version, please provide a detailed list of the changes made to the text, and a detailed list of your responses to the reviewers’ comments.
Please note that this editorial decision does not guarantee that your paper will be accepted for final publication in NHESS. A decision will be made when the revised version will be available, and will be evaluated.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli

Dear authors,
your paper has been further revised. Only minor to moderate issues remain in the text; pease check these. I will be glad to provide then a final editorial check before publication.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli

Dear authors,
Your paper is now ready for publication. There are just a few technical issues related to the fig. 17 and 18: 1) the scale bars are missed; 2) maybe a different range of colors (e.g. yellow and blue? or also, yellow and red?) or a different size of points should be better, since it is difficult to distinguish the shoreline position; also add the legend.
Thank you for submitting your work to NHESS.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli