Dear Indranil Kongar, Tiziana Rossetto, and Sonia Giovinazzi:

Thank you for your submission of "Evaluating Simplified Methods for Liquefaction Assessment for Loss Estimation", and your reply to two reviewers.

I now invite you to prepare a revised manuscript, a detailed reply for each comment from reviewers as to how the manuscript was (or was not) changed, and a track change document between the revised manuscript and the original manuscript. The author reply and the track change document should be joined together as one document.

I look forward to your revised manuscript.

Regards, Bruce D Malamud
NHESS Executive Editor

Dear Indranil Kongar, Tiziana Rossetto, and Sonia Giovinazzi:

First of all, my apologies in the delay in getting back to you. Thank you very much for the last set of minor revisions and the detailed track change document, along with reply to reviewer (and my own) comments. I am pleased to accept your publication in NHESS.

Thank you very much for submitting to NHESS, and I look forward to seeing your publication in print.

Regards, Bruce D Malamud